Skip to content
  • There are no suggestions because the search field is empty.

ACA (Major Medical) vs. Private Market

Understanding the differences between ACA-compliant plans (major medical) and private market options is essential for advising clients effectively.

ACA (Major Medical)

  • Overview: Enacted in 2010, the ACA established state-based Marketplaces where individuals can purchase plans with essential health benefits (e.g., hospitalization, prescription drugs, maternity care). Subsidies are available for those earning 100–400% of the federal poverty level, and insurers cannot deny coverage for pre-existing conditions.
  • Pros: Comprehensive coverage, premium subsidies, guaranteed issue, consumer protections (e.g., no lifetime limits).
  • Cons: Higher premiums for unsubsidized buyers, narrow provider networks (53% of 2017 Marketplace plans had limited networks, per McKinsey), complex enrollment.
  • Example: A family earning $40,000/year might get a subsidized silver plan with $200/month premiums but face a restricted provider list.

Private Market Options

  • Philadelphia American Life Insurance (Philadelphia American):
    • Overview: A trusted private insurer offering customizable health plans, partnered with American Ally for its client-focused approach.
    • Features: PPO Plans, competitive pricing, flexible options for individuals and families.
    • Pros: Wider doctor access, lower costs for healthy clients, streamlined enrollment.
    • Cons: Does not have “out of pocket max”, less suitable for subsidy-eligible clients or those with complex medical needs.
  • Short-Term Medical (STM):
    • Overview: Temporary plans (90 days) for coverage gaps (e.g., job transitions). Non-ACA-compliant, excluding benefits like maternity or mental health.
    • Pros: Affordable premiums, quick approval, ideal for healthy individuals.
    • Cons: Limited coverage, pre-existing condition exclusions, no subsidies. Critics, like the American College of Physicians, note STM plans can leave users underinsured.
    • Example: Aflac is the most well known.
  • Health share plans

    • Overview: Non-insurance programs where members share medical costs. Most are faith-based and require lifestyle agreements. Not ACA-compliant and not legally required to pay claims.

    • Features: Monthly share contributions, no networks, limited or no coverage for pre-existing conditions and certain services.

    • Pros: Low monthly cost, broad provider access, good fit for healthy individuals without subsidy eligibility.

    • Cons: No guarantees, exclusions for common needs (e.g., maternity, mental health), no subsidies or consumer protections.

    • Example: A couple in their 30s might pay $350/month with a $5,000 “unshareable amount,” but have limited maternity and prescription coverage.